Caroline married John Bulmer in 1862 and moved to Lake Tyers later the same year. She remained living there until just after her husband's death, when the Board for the Protection of the Aborigines refused her application, and denied the petition by the residents, to have her stay.
See: Victoria Haskins 2008, 'Give to us the People we would Love to be amongst us': The Aboriginal Campaign against Caroline Bulmer's Eviction from Lake Tyers Aboriginal Station, 1913-14, Provenance: The Journal of Public Record Office Victoria, Number 7.